0808 2000 247 Free phone 24 hr National Domestic Violence Helpline Run in partnership between Women’s Aid & Refuge
logo

Moderator: Lisa (WA moderator)

FORUM CLOSED: This is the archive. To return to the forum click 'Messageboard' on the left.

ARCHIVE - General

re, 50 shades of grey

Who wants to really read about a life you've just got out of !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Created by springflower on 5-Jul-12 20:22 GMT

Exactly

Hear hear!!

Posted by Ashley on 5-Jul-12 23:03 GMT

Agreed!!

Xx

Posted by lookinforward2 on 6-Jul-12 00:02 GMT

50 shades

Maybe there will be book 4 where she discovers that she has just landed herself in a whole world of abuse. Mr Grey a stalker in his own right ! the warning signals were there from the start. Book 5, she plots her escape ???

Posted by inneed1 on 6-Jul-12 08:12 GMT

I wish there was a like button for posts!!

Your right...all I can see in this book is the life I've worked hard to escape. I went though periods of thinking it was oh so devastatingly romantic and that I must have been his world...why else would he need to be so controlling and possessive..then I woke up!!

I read the first two chapters and thought it was crap...and to keep hearing about it grates to the core....50 Shade of STFU!!

Xx

Posted by lookinforward2 on 6-Jul-12 08:24 GMT

I only read the back of the book

That was enough for me , STUFF controlling men !!!!!!!!!

Posted by springflower on 6-Jul-12 08:49 GMT

find it horrifying

and think it shows the lack of knowledge in society and its down falls ...when everyones jumped on the band waggon to read it, especially those claiming its a feminist book ....saying this have only read about it online not the actual books like , but the extracts are horrifying enough and the fact supermarkets have none left on there shelves :( ....

Posted by impy on 6-Jul-12 11:13 GMT

It really makes you wonder

Why are the public going mad about books on abuse and heavy romantics that are usually the worst !!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by springflower on 6-Jul-12 11:20 GMT

I lasted til page 27 ..............

before deciding it was c**p - gave it away yesterday to someone who was desperate to read it x

Posted by sunshine on 6-Jul-12 12:34 GMT

Justification....

A friend of mine said to me that it was ok cos the female protagonist "willingly" participated. What I heard was that she signed a contract to do "whatever" he asked....without knowing what any of the things would be. I lost oatience and didn't bother putting forth my arguement that it used to be the same when you signed a marriage certificate (and to some men still is!) I mean, even the vow used to be to "obey" (only for the woman mind)
People bewilder me.

Posted by LadyBlahBlah on 6-Jul-12 13:03 GMT

Hi Ash

How are you.......

Posted by springflower on 6-Jul-12 23:01 GMT

Hi Impy

I just think it's mad how people are going mad........

Posted by springflower on 6-Jul-12 23:03 GMT

Horrible

I'm in a book club - someone suggested this book, everyone was talking about how great it was. I started reading it and it really, really upset me. I can't see how anyone can think it's exciting and sexy - I hate this about my life, being pressured into being submissive and being made to feel like if I don't then i'm a prude, or boring, or I don't like sex. I just don't want to be bullied and hurt and out of control. I don't understand who reads this and thinks it's fun!

Posted by Daisy55 on 7-Jul-12 00:17 GMT

you would hope so

what so good about , being over powered by one person, there is NO WAY I would go back in to that situation again ....... My boy's are my life know.

Posted by springflower on 7-Jul-12 16:18 GMT

it just shows the scars we all hold

it seems to really chasnge us as a person, after going to the H.... for counciling and talking about the way we cope with situations and how we should try to change the person we are ....!!!!!!!!!!!!!! surely it's them that should change not us!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by springflower on 7-Jul-12 16:25 GMT

This book is everywhere!

Youngest (student on summer break from uni) just started a cleaning job the other day. All the cleaners gathered in their little staff room for their break this morning and talked about the amazing book they're all reading...

Yes, you guessed it... Abuse in 50 grades!

Posted by Flowerchild on 7-Jul-12 18:42 GMT

Thats why she does the job she has.........

I know that was mean and I know some people can only do those kind of jobs for short times / summer jobs, but why are people so thick not to notice things like this. or is it just we are too awere of things after all we've been through !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by springflower on 8-Jul-12 00:59 GMT

Oh Springflower, I'm glad you said that not me!

I thought it though. And you're right, the ones reading the book are in the job year round. They asked if she'd read it, and whether she watched Eastenders. That sums it up. Apols to 'stenders fans reading this, I know it has its merits! She plans to avoid the fuss by taking in her reading for her dissertation that she's working on over the summer. Bet she doesn't get any reading done though! Oh, and to add insult to injury, they are bigoted and racist in their conversation too, the sort of 'Coming over here taking our jobs and claiming benefit at our expense' line. She will end up challenging because she's incensed by those attitudes.


But maybe 50 Grades of Garbage is a vultural phenomenon

Posted by Flowerchild on 8-Jul-12 08:27 GMT

Sorry, lost control of diddy screen!

Meant to finish:

a cultural phenomenon that cuts through all the layers of our society and reaches women of every type and all levels of education!

Posted by Flowerchild on 8-Jul-12 08:34 GMT

so well put

I couldn't have phrased it better if I tried :) :)

Posted by springflower on 8-Jul-12 18:30 GMT